Many individual investors fall into a common behavioural trap known as overtrading — making too many buys and sells in an attempt to chase short‑term gains or react to market noise. While active trading can feel empowering, it often leads to higher transaction costs, poor timing decisions, and worse long‑term performance compared with a more disciplined approach. According to experienced market coaches, overtrading tends to be driven by emotion — fear of missing out on the next big move, or anxiety about short‑term price swings — rather than sound investment strategy.
One straightforward rule some traders use to counter this tendency is the “15‑trade rule.” This guideline suggests that instead of jumping in and out of positions constantly, investors should limit themselves to a predetermined number of meaningful trades over a set period. The logic is simple: limiting how often you trade reduces the impact of impulsive decisions, encourages more thoughtful analysis before entering or exiting a position, and helps avoid unnecessary costs that eat into returns. By creating this kind of self‑imposed guardrail, you can break the habit of reacting to every headline or price tick.
Overtrading doesn’t just increase commissions and fees — even in low‑cost platforms — it can also have tax consequences for investors in taxable accounts. Frequent selling of short‑term positions often means gains are taxed at higher ordinary income rates, whereas longer holding periods can qualify for more favourable treatment. Even in tax‑advantaged accounts, however, excessive turnover can reduce overall returns because you’re essentially betting against transaction friction and your own timing instincts.
Also Read: Top Canadian tech AI stocks
Behavioral finance research shows that most amateur investors underperform broad market indices over time precisely because of this trading behaviour. Frequent moves in and out of stocks or funds can feel like progress — “at least I’m doing something” — but in practice, it usually results in buying high and selling low. A disciplined limit on the number of trades flips that mindset: it forces you to do better upfront research, define your investment thesis clearly, and stick with positions long enough to benefit from actual business performance rather than moment‑to‑moment market noise.
Also Read: Best long term Canadian stocks
In practice, the “15‑trade rule” is not a magic number but rather a reminder to think before acting. Whether you choose 10, 15, or 20 meaningful position decisions per year, the intent is the same: trade less and think more. This approach tends to favour long‑term wealth building over short‑term reacting, and helps align your behaviour with the time horizons that successful investing typically requires.
Sign Up For our Newsletters to get latest updates
