Shopify Reports Record Revenue But Stock Slides on Valuation Concerns

Shopify delivered its strongest quarterly performance in company history with fourth-quarter revenue reaching $3.67 billion, up 31% year-over-year, but shares tumbled more than 12% as investors questioned whether current valuations adequately reflect execution risks in the AI commerce transition.

The Ottawa-based e-commerce platform exceeded analyst expectations on both top and bottom lines, posting earnings per share of 57 cents against forecasts of 51 cents. Gross merchandise volume, representing total sales transacted across Shopify’s platform, grew 30% as the company continued gaining market share in both core U.S. markets and international territories including Europe. Management announced a $2 billion share buyback program, signaling confidence in the business fundamentals.

Shopify’s strategic pivot toward AI-powered shopping represents both significant opportunity and uncertainty. The company has integrated its merchant platform with ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot, allowing consumers to discover and purchase products through conversational interfaces. Orders originating from AI searches increased 15-fold between January 2025 and January 2026, demonstrating rapid early adoption. However, the four percent fee charged to merchants selling through OpenAI’s platform has raised questions about merchant willingness to pay premium fees for incremental distribution channels.

Also Read: Top Canadian tech AI stocks

Management’s first-quarter guidance called for revenue growth in the “low-thirties percentage rate,” consistent with Q4’s pace but below some investor expectations for acceleration. The company expects gross profit dollar growth around the high-20% range as it continues investing in AI capabilities and merchant tools.

Also Read: Long term investing in Canada

Shopify’s Sidekick AI assistant generated nearly 4,000 custom apps and completed over 1.2 million photo edits in just three weeks since launch, suggesting strong merchant engagement with productivity tools. While near-term stock pressure reflects valuation concerns, analysts maintaining Buy ratings point to Shopify’s superior commerce data assets and minimal headcount growth as drivers of expanding margins in coming quarters.